Get the Red Out

Before I painted it, both my front door and front stoop were a muddy red… literally.  After choosing new paint colors for the house, I decided to remove the storm door and paint the front door a deep, moody blue.  But since there were more pressing projects on the interior, the front stoop remained the same (it’s always dirty and half-blown pine straw, so there never seemed to be a good time to paint it).

I left things alone out front, but to the detriment of the curb appeal; the red of the front stoop stands out and simply doesn’t mesh well with the rest of the house.

After scrubbing things down on Sunday, I’m ready to paint it and get rid of the red.  However, I realized I’m trying to choose between two options:  do I paint it blue to match the door (just like the red door and red stoop matched), or go with making it look more like concrete and paint it gray? My original choice was blue, so I already picked up patio paint in the same hue.  But now that I’ve had the chance to wait on making the decision, I’m finding that time has made me question my original choice.  So, I turned to my old friend, Photoshop.

 

What would you choose?  Blue, gray, or something else (I’ve even gone so far as to think of a cool tile pattern like this in blue and cream – the color of the trim paint – but that may be too much)?  Thoughts?

Sarah

Comments

  1. Anonymous says

    I vote blue… it's not something you see every day. And I love that it ties in with the door.

  2. Lia says

    Blue would stand out more, but that may not be the look you want. Tough decision! I do not envy you at all.

  3. says

    Definitely not the blue, as even though it is a close match to the door, well…errrr, that is the problem you see. It is a “close” match, but not exact. The gray is much better, but would be curious to see the cream color. If it is light enough, that might work even better than he gray. Just my two cents worth!

  4. says

    Of the two, I'd say go with the gray. The blue is “too close without being right on”, so I find it a bit distracting. I'm intrigued by the thought of the cream color though. In my mind's eye, I see that as even better than the gray!

  5. Anonymous says

    I'd go for a charcoal or putty gray (a darker, moodier shade of the gray tone in your rocks). The contrast will look great and I think it would look more interesting/pulled together than blue-on-blue or even a brown porch that blends into the siding. Plus, you could always bring in the blue of your door via some nice ceramic pots down the line (one in the navy of your door and another one or two in shades of teal?).

  6. says

    Gray in a tone of your rocks. The mortar would be nice, or perhaps a darker shade. Think to hide dirt and go with a “cool” gray to match the door, and not a “warm” gray. :)

  7. says

    Gray all the way!! I think it's a bit too much blue (just in the matchy-matchy way) and the gray complements the door nicely :) That way the door will really pop!

  8. says

    I would say gray so the door is more of a focal point, the blue porch would take attention away from it.

  9. says

    i would pick up one of the colors in the stones… not the gray in the photo… not the dark blue either… but a darker gray maybe or a darker tan…

  10. says

    I agree with Southern Gal and put my vote towards pulling out on of the colors in the stones. I think gray might be too contrasting with all the brown and tan that is the oeverall scheme of the front.

  11. says

    Definitely grey. The blue would detract attention from the door, which I think should be your focal point. And grey will hide dirt better than blue. The blue will just look dusty if you don't keep it scrubbed down. Although I am certainly intrigued by the idea of a grey/cream pattern.

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy: I love comments, especially if they make me laugh. Feel free to let your words of wisdom and humor fly (there's no swear jar on this blog), but if you're overly spammy, rude, or just plain boring, you're just going to have to accept that your comment may not see the light of day.