Disclosure: this post may contain affiliate links, which means I may make a commission if you decide to make a purchase through one of my links, at no cost to you.

So, I have this amazing walnut butcher block countertop.

It cost me well more than the Ikea butcher block alternative I was considering (about a $400 difference in total cost). But after that first coat of oil and beeswax soaked into the wood (read about why I chose this mixture here), bringing out all of its gorgeous color variation, I was forever smitten. I had made the right choice. However, when it comes to finishing off various other projects in the kitchen, such as the tiled backsplash, there are certain steps that proved to be a little more difficult thanks to this oiled coating.

(Before we go into all of those items, there is one question I wanted to answer first:  why didn’t I just wait to oil them until after? The answer is pretty simple:  in order to protect those raw wood counters against everything else that would come into contact with them, they needed to be treated asap. For moisture reasons, for stain reasons, for water protection reasons (and I wasn’t about to go months of not having a usable sink!)… the counter needed to be oiled before getting to any of the other finishing projects. Especially since things have been progressing so slowly. If I had waited, and they were somehow damaged in the process, I would be kicking my own ass for being so stupid. For more info on the countertop treatment itself, click back to this post)

For one, painter’s tape won’t stick. Which meant that installing the tile (with its various steps of sticky substances like thinset, grout, and caulk) wasn’t always going to work out the way most of the tutorials I’d researched told me. I wasn’t going to be able to protect my counters with paper and tape the way others had. I also wasn’t going to be able to use tape to provide a nice, clean line of caulk between the tile and counter. So, what to do?

For one thing, I relied pretty heavily on plastic wrap. It was clingy enough to form to the surface (and fit within the 1/8″ gap under the tile when grouting), but didn’t require any kind of adhesives to stick. I used plastic wrap for both the installation of the tile with thinset, and again for grouting the tile after the thinset had cured.

I used tape sometimes to attach the plastic wrap to the first line of tape (since that surface had zero sticking issues) as I worked my way up the rest of the wall. The plastic wrap did a great job of catching all of the wet drips and clumps from both the thinset and grout. And when I left the room to allow the tile to cure, I just collected the plastic wrap in sections, folding the piece closest to the tile inward (to prevent anything from slipping off the wrap and onto the counter), and folded the rest of the corners in too. This caught any clumps (dried or otherwise) into the center of the wrap, which I could then toss into the trash. I used new pieces of plastic wrap between the thinset step and grout step to keep things clean.

The other workaround I found was the counter itself. I’d been debating whether to try to dry the counter out a little to see if the tape would stick (it didn’t) or just to keep it nicely oiled as a means of creating a slick, non-stick surface. I eventually realized option #2 was my only logical choice. Because the surface was already oily, it sort of kept a nice protective barrier to anything that dripped on it (which is sort of the reason for applying the oil in the first place as a regular countertop treatment against food and other everyday things). All I had to do if I spotted a wet clump of grout sitting on the surface was wipe it down with a wet towel. Even if I’d missed it before it dried, just a little bit of scraping with my fingernail or my putty knife did the trick.

Finally, when it came time to apply a line of caulk, I used the putty knife once more. It was as simple as applying the bead of caulk as I always did, and smoothing it out with a gloved finger (the caulk is a latex/silicone mix).

Then, I ran the putty knife along the tile to keep it perfectly straight as it collected any excess caulk. (Tip:  put a little pressure on the end that’s up against the caulk line to get everything in one scrape). Again, because of the oiled surface, the caulk came up clean.

And boom, straight line!

Easy, right? What did you work on this weekend?

P.S. I’m still working on the solution of how the caulk managed to yellow overnight (lots of you guys suggested that it was the oil in the countertop or the walnut itself that had caused the yellowing, which I thought too at first, but the caulk yellowed in other areas that weren’t touching the counter at all, so it seems to have more to do with the thickness of application; only the thicker areas yellowed while the rest has stayed white… plus my contact at DAP also seems to think it’s another issue). I’ll keep  you guys updated on that when I finally figure out what caused it.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy: I love comments, especially if they make me laugh. Feel free to let your words of wisdom and humor fly (there's no swear jar on this blog), but if you're overly spammy, rude, or just plain boring, you're just going to have to accept that your comment may not see the light of day. P.S. If you leave an affiliate or monetized link when making a comment on this site, such links might get overwritten by a plugin I have installed that uses my own internal tracking. See terms and disclosure page for more info! Thanks in advance. You rock.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

17 Comments

  1. Thats so weird it yellowed like that! Do you have to rip it all out or just cover it with another coat? You make caulking look so easy. I have good days and bad days with it. My fine motor skills arent the best lol

  2. Awsome! Of course if the countertop won’t let tape stick, it won’t let any other sort of gooey drippage stick. Brilliant and way too simple for me to figure out.

  3. Great blog. I like the variations of colors in the butcher block. It has a bit of a rustic look especially with the white tiles. Such a benefit that the oil allowed for the caulk to come out easily. You used a lot of precision and were definitely meticulous which shows with the clean lines. Nice work!

  4. I have a terrible time making caulk look nice. I am sure I need more practice.

    Your lines are perfect! The countertop was a wonderful choice!

  5. Really important tips for protecting the oiled butcher block countertop . Using that plastic wrap is really a very good idea. Keep posting such stuff. Thank you.

  6. I know this is 3 years old but I am reeeeeally hoping you might still see this, as I’m in a pickle! I did the same as you and oiled my butcher block top before installing it to protect it. My major problem is that the caulk isn’t sticking! It sticks to the tile obviously but no the oiled wood. Can you tell me what exactly you ended up using for caulk and if you ran into the same issue? Thank you very much.

    1. I wound up using white silicone caulk. It’s goopy and not a lot of fun to work with, but it was the ONLY kind I could find that wouldn’t turn mysteriously yellow once I started oiling the counter. It wasn’t so much the lack of sticking (I found that other types WOULD stick), but the silicone one was the only one that wouldn’t yellow over time. I’ve been meaning to do a post update about this, so thank you for the reminder. I can directly compare the two, years later, and show you how the silicone version kept up to the regular kind.

      1. Huh. The silicone caulk I used won’t stick to the counter. What brand did you use? Maybe it’s a matter of quality. I just used the standard DAP 100% silicone caulk. Maybe it was too freshly oiled and I need to try again. I bought a few other things to experiment with, one is a polyurethane caulk. Thanks for the reply!

        1. I did let my counter dry out a little bit, but I too used DAP. It was sticky and gooey (I had to be careful to scrape off excess in a straight line), which took some time and effort, but it stuck for me! If you’re having problems, I recommend calling DAP and telling them your problem… they wound up shipping me a couple of tubes to try out based on their recommendation (and I think they would have done this for any consumer).

  7. This blog may have turned out to be a life-saver. My wife is a very dangerous person who spends a great deal of time looking for ideas on DIY blogs like this. Over the years that has led to a number of different adventures like butcher block counter tops. When you look at the labels on tubes of silicon caulk they recommend not using oil based paints. Well that was a FABULOUS thing to read 6 hours after installing the counter top that we plan to prep with mineral oil. So we’re going with some GE Silicone for kitchen and bath. I’ll let you know how things turn out in a month or so. Thanks for posting these comments, they gave me either the confidence to move forward or the false security to think …meh, I can always fix it later…

    1. Glad I could help in any way! I would say that the new caulk I used held the white WAY better than what I tried before, so hopefully it works alright for you too. And true, with most DIY, if it doesn’t turn out the way you hoped (at least with caulk!), there is little time and effort invested and can be undone.

  8. How is your DAP caulk working out? I just put in my backsplash and found out this may be a problem after realizing painters tape won’t stick.

    Read some of the previous comments just curious if it’s still going strong

    1. I used white silicone caulk for the edge and that was what I wound up using long-term. Still no problem after many years, but it takes a little more effort to make sure you scrape it off of the surface where you don’t want it to go.

  9. Hi!
    I am just about to start a backsplash project and I also have butcher block countertops. I wasn’t sure what to do about the seam between the counter and backsplash and then saw your article. Can you share what type of DAP caulk you used?
    Thanks!
    Kate

    1. Hi Kate! I wound up using 100% pure silicone white caulk. It seemed to be the only one that didn’t yellow (I tried the silicone easy-cleanup ones and didn’t have very good success).