Disclosure: this post may contain affiliate links, which means I may make a commission if you decide to make a purchase through one of my links, at no cost to you.

Yesterday I mentioned that I painted my front door, but hadn’t yet shared what color I painted it. Here is what the old gal looked like before:
Red door

When you opened the (broken) storm door, it looked like this:

Red door

The storm door removal is still a project for another day, but I couldn’t wait to get a new color on the door. That old paint was grody, guys. Originally, I planned to use Behr’s Dark as Night as recommended by the Behr Colorsmart online tool (it’s was a suggested accent color with the Rustic Cream trim and Basketry colors I’d already painted the house with), but when looking at the combo in the store, the color just seemed a little too light and dull.

I wanted something dark and dramatic. Moody, even. Dark as Night is a great name, but not a great color. But it’s cousin (and right next to it, color swatch wise), Night Shade, seemed like the right fit.

Color chips

It was a color gamble (and those don’t usually work out for me, but I do them anyway), but I figured that anything would be better than having to look at this all the time:

Red painted cement on the front porch

After a thorough cleaning and some prep work with my favorite deglosser (love not having to sand!),

Cut in the panels first

I got to work. I used a brush in the nooks and crannies I knew I couldn’t reach otherwise, then went over the entire surface with a foam roller for the smoothest finish. Here she is with the first coat (yikes), but it’s not staying that way for long!

First coat of paint on door

I did three more coats. The last one probably wasn’t necessary, but I wanted to make sure everything was covered (and the changing light throughout the day can point you to places that aren’t as evenly covered). In case you’re wondering, I chose a semi-gloss exterior latex. The sheen will help with durability and make cleaning easier.

can of Behr premium plus paint

I started painting in the morning in the hopes of being able to close the door by the time I went to bed. Just to be on the safe side while it was still drying, I draped a sheet of wax paper over the top (where I thought the biggest problem with sticking might take place). To keep things simple, I also protected the door knob and deadbolt with tape and aluminum foil so that I didn’t have to try to reattach them while the paint was still drying.

Covered doorknobs with tape and foil

So here she is. She doesn’t pop like the red did, but I like it against the creamy white and medium tan color (which kind of reminds me of cookies). The navy, tan and creamy white color combo is classic, and when I install shutters, the navy will look even better.

New Door color
Front of house
Front of house
New door color from the road
Close-up of new paint color on door

What do you think? Stay tuned for more updates like the knocker paint-over, new house numbers, and a pretty fall wreath to dress up the door even more. And that’s not even all of the stoop makeover – there’s still more to come (like freshening up that decorative stone work on the side of the door).

Sarah signature

Did you enjoy this post? Please subscribe to get the latest updates delivered to your reader or inbox for free!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy: I love comments, especially if they make me laugh. Feel free to let your words of wisdom and humor fly (there's no swear jar on this blog), but if you're overly spammy, rude, or just plain boring, you're just going to have to accept that your comment may not see the light of day. P.S. If you leave an affiliate or monetized link when making a comment on this site, such links might get overwritten by a plugin I have installed that uses my own internal tracking. See terms and disclosure page for more info! Thanks in advance. You rock.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. I agree, it doesn't pop, but it does the give the house this “air” about it saying “look at me, I'm classic and amazing”. Love the color!

    Great job!

  2. I love it! We're doing a yellow/tan/brown/navy combo on our exterior, too – whenever we actually get around to it. :) I really love the color you picked – it's dark and moody, and goes perfect with the rest of the house!


  3. That definitely works! I really like the color and I think it will go perfect with the other color choices you made. Keep the photos coming!

  4. I just found your blog! I'm in the 'burbs of Atl, and am about to paint my front door too. How did you deal with the faded brass and holes from you kickplate?

  5. Did you only paint the outside of the door? I love the new color, I love red but I also have a red bathroom in the house that we just bought that I don’t love. I’ll be repainting it soon. But I want to paint my front door a dark color, haven’t decided what yet, it’s currently white. My husband thinks that we should just paint the outside of the door and leave the white inside because the dark would make the living room look darker, and wouldn’t match with our white crown molding, baseboards and trim. What do you think?

    1. The inside was painted ivory originally. So when I painted over the red, I just painted the outside and left the inside the same. Eventually, I decided a black door would be interesting on the inside (for contrast), so I painted the inside a shiny black. Here is the post on that if you want to check it out!

  6. Hi Sarah! How did you remove the kickplate on the door? I’m about to embark on that same journey!